• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Global Patent Research and Alerts | Pearson Strategy Group, LLC

Helping businesses look before they leap. - TM

  • HOW WE HELP
    • Overview of Services
    • Patent Searches
      • Innovation Strategy
      • Patent Analytics
    • Patent Searches for Patent Attorneys
    • Keep Up with Your Industry and Competition
      • Patent Alerts
        • Live Alert Demonstrations
          • Additive Manufacturing – Recent Patents and Applications Alert
          • Aerial Drones (UAVs) – Recent Patents and Applications Alert
          • Blockchain – Recent Patents and Applications Alert
      • Recognize Your Threats, Opportunities
        • Adjacent Technology Example
        • Emerging Technology Example
        • Disruptive Technology Example
      • Competitive Intelligence
      • Custom Market Research
    • Additional Support
      • Frequently Asked Questions
  • ABOUT
    • About Us
    • Meet the Founder
    • Alliance Partners
    • Philosophy
    • Trusted Suppliers
  • SUCCESS STORIES
  • CONTACT
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
  • NEWSLETTER
  • BLOG
  • Search

Schrödinger’s Patent: The Paradox of When a Novel Idea is Really Patented

Where in the Patent Process Does an Idea Exist? Or Does It?

Schrödinger Cat Illustration

Can something be simultaneously alive and dead? This is the question posed in the famous thought experiment conducted by Austrian physicist Erwin Schrödinger in 1935. [1] Paraphrasing to eliminate a few scientific and gory details, he surmised that placing a live cat in a box would eventually lead to the question of when it stops being alive if you have no way of monitoring the cat or opening the box.

This same debate might also be applied to the many inventors, attorneys and companies involved in deciding when a novel idea is really (substitute “effectively” if you wish) confirmed as being novel.

Why should I care? I’ve noticed that many people consider their idea to be “patented” as soon as their “provisional patent” (their terms) has been filed. A number of people are planning on getting a “world-wide patent” (again, their terms) something which does not exist.

The quandary is that patent protection of unique ideas has several “states.” Ah, yes, now we’re back to the paradox posed by Schrödinger.

A few examples:

Germination?

Provisional Patent Applications are filed at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) to protect an idea with minimal effort and expense. The paradox is that these documents are not published and they are not reviewed by the USPTO. In this state, only the inventor and anyone who helped draft the application know the contents. The USPTO knows that the inventor filed the application but nothing more.

So, does the idea really exist outside the inventor’s mind? Of course, the quandary is broken anytime the inventor discloses the details of his or her application with another person.

Incubation?

A Non-provisional Patent Application is known to exist by the public after the USPTO publishes it, commonly 18 months after the filing date. The USPTO doesn’t know the contents until the first office action, commonly one to three years later.

Schrödenger might propose that the contents of the application are unknown until publicized or until the first office action. Another quandary is whether the application will ever turn into a granted patent with accompanying legal benefits. In this pre-grant state we don’t know whether the application will be abandoned, patent granted, or whether only a portion of the claims will be granted.

Birth?

Granted Patents are, at least in theory, known by the public as soon as the document is published.

But Schrödenger might ask questions such as:

• Does the patent really exist if it’s not easily discoverable in a patent search (some patents are not)
• Does it exist if it’s not being commercialized or monetized (the desired outcome for most inventors)?
• Does it really exist if the owner isn’t monitoring for infringers (assuming that it’s not part of a purely defensive strategy) allowing others to essentially diminish what might have been a novel idea at the time?

Would Erwin Schrödinger bring in a philosophical debate that a patent hasn’t achieved maturity until the novel idea contained in it is making money or being commercialized? What do you think?

 

Picture credits: Anarkman~commonswiki and Nobel foundation (Wikimedia)

[1] Schrödinger’s cat (Wikipedia)

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

sidebar

Blog Sidebar

Subscribe to Our Newsletter Overview of Our Services Schedule a Consultation

Recent Posts

  • Intellectual Property Strategy for SaaS Startups
  • How to Confidently Decide Between a Provisional and Non-Provisional Patent Application for Your Invention
  • Summer 2021 Newsletter from Steve Pearson
  • How to Leverage the Amazon Brand Registry
  • Approaching Patent Valuations, Common Methods and Qualifications of Analysts
  • Understanding Patents and the Need for Valuation: The Basics
  • Summer 2020 Newsletter

Footer

Let’s Talk

What to expect. Sample reports. Pricing.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent News

Andrew Rapacke

Intellectual Property Strategy for SaaS Startups

From Steve: Please welcome returning guest blogger Andrew Rapacke. Andrew is the managing partner at The Rapacke Law Group, a full-service intellectual property law firm. Andrew’s post examines several important topics software companies need to Read More

Randi Karpinia

How to Confidently Decide Between a Provisional and Non-Provisional Patent Application for Your Invention

From Steve: This Guest blog by Randi L. Karpinia, esq. covers what could be the most common inventor question. Randi Karpinia, author of Sagacity Legal’s “The Legal Blog”, helps small businesses and entrepreneurs minimize their legal risks. Read More

Social Media

TwitterYoutubeLinkedin


Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

Phone: 1-512-466-1450 | Email: innovate@pearsonstrategy.com

© 2023 Pearson Strategy Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved